• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

https://tennisfixation.com/

  • Home
  • Real Tennis Tips Book
  • Tennis Quick Tips Podcast
  • Favorite Tennis Resources
  • Blog
  • About
    • About Kim
    • About Tennis Fixation
  • Archives
  • Let’s Chat!

If It’s Out, Call It Out!

February 2, 2012 by kselz

So this just happened to me in a recent doubles match – in the middle of a point, I was on the ad side and my partner was on the deuce side and both of us were back around the baseline. I was close to mid-court and hit a forehand down the line that hit the outside line of the doubles alley (as I saw it) and angled away from my opponent. She reached for the ball but missed. She then said, “I wasn't really looking at the ball so I can't say if it was in or out. Can we replay the point?”

Now you and I know that, once my opponent expressed any doubt at all about calling the ball in or out, the point was mine. Because if you can't positively say that a ball was out, then it was in and (in the above situation) you lose the point.

How do we know this? Well, let's start with ITF Rule of Tennis 12 which states:

If a ball touches a line, it is regarded as touching the court bounded by that line.

Seems pretty clear. But the USTA has added their own Comment 12.1 to this rule which further explains:

If a player cannot call a ball out with certainty, should the player regard the ball as good? Yes. The Code sec. 6 and sec. 8 require a player to give the opponent the benefit of any doubt.

So let's look at The Code – The Player's Guide for Matches When Officials are not Present. Section 6 states:

6. Opponent gets benefit of doubt.  When a match is played without officials, the players are responsible for making decisions, particularly for line calls. There is a subtle difference between player decisions and those of an on-court official. An official impartially resolves a problem involving a call, whereas a player is guided by the unwritten rule that any doubt must be resolved in favor of an opponent. A player in attempting to be scrupulously honest on line calls frequently will keep a ball in play that might have been out or that the player discovers too late was out. Even so, the game is much better played this way.

If that doesn't make it crystal clear, let's look at Section 8:

8. Ball that cannot be called out is good. Any ball that cannot be called out is considered to be good. A player may not claim a let on the basis of not seeing a ball. One of tennis' most infuriating moments occurs after a long hard rally when a player makes a clean placement and an opponent says: “I'm not sure if it was good or out. Let's play a let.” Remember, it is each player's responsibility to call all balls landing on, or aimed at, the player's side of the net. If a ball cannot be called out with certainty, it is good. When a player says an opponent's shot was really out but offers to replay the point to give the opponent a break, it seems clear that the player actually doubted that the ball was out.

Infuriating? That's putting it mildly.

Here's what ultimately happened in my match and I'm not happy about it. I said, “No, we're not playing a let. If you have any doubt, then the ball's in.” My partner said, “You have to call the ball in or out.” My opponent's partner said, “It's not a let. You have to call the ball.”

So I'll bet you can guess what happened next. My opponent said, “Oh, well the ball was out. I was just trying to be nice.” I absolutely could not believe it!

My partner and I did not argue but REALLY???  You're calling it OUT??? And honestly, my problem is not that my opponent called my fabulous shot out. It's that she was so OBVIOUSLY in doubt about the call and then had the nerve to make a late call and to call it out. If you're going to call a ball out, even if its a blatantly bad call, man up and call it out quickly and forcefully.

And I'll admit – while I'm mad at my opponent, I'm even madder at myself for letting her get away with this. My very poor excuse is that I was in shock over the fact that she called the ball out!

Next time, no more Mrs. Nice Guy from me. I don't care if this is a “fun” league and we're all out to have a good time. I'm not backing down. I'm not letting it go. And I'm not going into shock. I'm whipping out my rule book and taking my point.


© Kim Selzman 2012 All Rights Reserved

Share Tennis Fixation with your friends

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window) Pinterest
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email

Filed Under: Doubles, Tennis Rules Tagged With: doubles, lets, rules

Previous Post: « Tennis Fixation’s 2012 Australian Open Wrap-Up
Next Post: The Tag Heuer Watch – As Worn By Me And Maria Sharapova »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. deja

    February 4, 2012 at 12:27 am

    The USTA leagues are about having ‘fun” and having a good time. But it’s a competitive league and the rules must be followed by everyone. That’s what makes it fun!!!!

Primary Sidebar

Are You Fixated on Tennis?

So am I! You want to improve your game but have fun at the same time? Me too! Hi! I'm Kim and I'm an ordinary tennis player, just like you, so click HERE to read what I'm thinking about and working on and maybe we can improve our tennis games together!

Click for the Podcast

Tennis Quick Tips Podcast

Click to Get the Book on Amazon

I’m an ITPA Tennis Performance Trainer

Tennis Performance Trainer

Top TF Posts

  • Simple Serve Tips: How and Why to Use the Continental Grip on Your Serve - Tennis Quick Tips Podcast 105
    Simple Serve Tips: How and Why to Use the Continental Grip on Your Serve - Tennis Quick Tips Podcast 105
  • What's the Tennis Rule on Double Bounces? Tennis Quick Tips Podcast 55
    What's the Tennis Rule on Double Bounces? Tennis Quick Tips Podcast 55
  • How Many Vibration Dampeners Can You Have On Your Tennis Racquet?
    How Many Vibration Dampeners Can You Have On Your Tennis Racquet?
  • What to Do When Your Opponent Is Moving During Your Serve - Tennis Quick Tips Podcast 190
    What to Do When Your Opponent Is Moving During Your Serve - Tennis Quick Tips Podcast 190
  • "Weird" Tennis Rules: Reaching Over The Net
    "Weird" Tennis Rules: Reaching Over The Net

Click for More on These Topics

  • Backhand
  • Best Tennis Tips
  • Doubles
  • Fitness & Nutrition
  • Forehand
  • Fun Stuff
  • Gear & Equipment
  • Lessons & Coaching
  • Lob & Drop Shot
  • Mental Game
  • Podcast
  • Return
  • Serve
  • Singles
  • Strategy
  • Strokes & Technique
  • Style & Fashion
  • Tennis Books
  • Tennis Rules
  • The Pros
  • Tips & Tricks
  • Volleys
SiteLock

Footer

TENNIS FIXATION

Looking For More? Search Here:

CLICK FOR:

  • ADVERTISING POLICY & LIABILITY DISCLAIMER
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • ADVERTISE AND PARTNER WITH ME
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy

Copyright © 2025 https://tennisfixation.com/ on the Foodie Pro Theme